Which Country Makes the Best Blue Cheese? A Deep Dive into Creamy, Piquant Perfection

Blue cheese. The very name evokes strong reactions. Some recoil at the pungent aroma, while others are immediately transported to a world of creamy, complex flavors. It’s a cheese that demands attention, a culinary experience that’s both challenging and rewarding. But with so many countries producing blue cheese, a vital question arises: Which country truly makes the “best”? The answer, as with most subjective culinary pursuits, is nuanced and depends heavily on personal preference. However, we can delve into the history, production methods, and unique characteristics of blue cheese from various nations to provide a well-rounded perspective.

Table of Contents

The Allure of Blue Cheese: A World of Flavor

Blue cheese derives its distinctive character from the introduction of Penicillium cultures during the cheesemaking process. These cultures, typically Penicillium roqueforti, Penicillium glaucum, or Penicillium candidum, contribute to the cheese’s characteristic blue or green veins and its sharp, often salty flavor. The mold grows within the cheese, breaking down proteins and fats, creating a symphony of flavors that range from fruity and nutty to spicy and intensely savory.

The texture of blue cheese can vary greatly, from crumbly and dry to smooth and creamy, depending on the type of milk used (cow, sheep, or goat) and the cheesemaking techniques employed. The aging process also plays a crucial role, with longer aging resulting in more intense and complex flavors.

France: The Birthplace of Blue Cheese Royalty

France holds a special place in the world of blue cheese, as it is home to some of the most iconic and revered varieties. The history of French blue cheese dates back centuries, and its production is deeply intertwined with the country’s agricultural traditions.

Roquefort: The King of Blues

Perhaps the most famous of all blue cheeses, Roquefort, is produced exclusively in the Roquefort-sur-Soulzon region of southern France. This cheese is made from the milk of Lacaune sheep and is aged in natural limestone caves, where the Penicillium roqueforti mold thrives. The caves provide the ideal temperature and humidity for the cheese to develop its characteristic flavor and texture. Roquefort is known for its sharp, salty, and tangy flavor, with a creamy, crumbly texture. Its complex aroma is often described as earthy and slightly barnyardy. The legally protected designation of origin (AOP) ensures that only cheese produced in this specific region, following traditional methods, can be called Roquefort.

Bleu d’Auvergne: A Volcanic Delight

Originating from the Auvergne region of central France, Bleu d’Auvergne is made from cow’s milk. It is known for its creamy texture and its sharp, pungent flavor with hints of spice. The cheese is traditionally pierced with needles to allow air to circulate, promoting the growth of the Penicillium glaucum mold. While not as intensely flavored as Roquefort, Bleu d’Auvergne offers a delightful balance of flavors and a smooth, lingering finish. Its relatively affordable price and wide availability have made it a popular choice among blue cheese enthusiasts.

Fourme d’Ambert: A Gentle Giant

Also hailing from the Auvergne region, Fourme d’Ambert is another cow’s milk blue cheese. However, it distinguishes itself through its milder flavor profile. It boasts a creamy, almost buttery texture and a subtle sweetness that complements the characteristic blue cheese tang. Fourme d’Ambert is typically produced in a tall, cylindrical shape, and its gentle flavor makes it an excellent choice for those new to blue cheese or those who prefer a less assertive taste. Its versatility allows it to be used in a wide range of culinary applications, from salads to sauces.

Italy: Blue Cheese with a Mediterranean Twist

While France may be the undisputed king of blue cheese, Italy offers its own unique contributions to the world of erborinati, the Italian term for blue cheese. Italian blue cheeses often reflect the country’s diverse terroir and culinary traditions.

Gorgonzola: Creamy, Tangy, and Versatile

Gorgonzola, originating from the Lombardy region of northern Italy, is perhaps the most well-known Italian blue cheese. It’s made from cow’s milk and comes in two main varieties: Gorgonzola Dolce (sweet) and Gorgonzola Piccante (spicy). Gorgonzola Dolce is creamy, mild, and slightly sweet, with a subtle tang. Gorgonzola Piccante, on the other hand, is aged longer and has a firmer texture and a sharper, more pronounced flavor. Gorgonzola is incredibly versatile and can be enjoyed on its own, in salads, pasta dishes, or as a topping for pizza. Its creamy texture makes it ideal for spreading on bread or crackers.

Other Italian Blues: A Regional Tapestry

Beyond Gorgonzola, Italy boasts a variety of regional blue cheeses, each with its own distinct characteristics. Some examples include Blu di Bufala (made from buffalo milk), which offers a rich and creamy flavor, and Castelmagno, a semi-hard cheese with blue veining and a complex, nutty flavor. These lesser-known Italian blues provide a glimpse into the country’s rich cheesemaking heritage.

The United Kingdom: Blue Cheese Innovation

The United Kingdom has a long and proud tradition of cheesemaking, and its blue cheeses are known for their quality and distinctive flavor profiles. British blue cheeses often exhibit a bold and assertive flavor, reflecting the country’s culinary preferences.

Stilton: The Quintessential British Blue

Stilton, often referred to as the “King of English Cheeses,” is a PDO (Protected Designation of Origin) cheese produced in only three counties: Derbyshire, Leicestershire, and Nottinghamshire. Made from cow’s milk, Stilton is known for its rich, creamy texture and its complex flavor, which is both savory and slightly sweet. The cheese is aged for several months, during which time the Penicillium roqueforti mold develops, creating the characteristic blue veins and pungent aroma. Stilton is traditionally enjoyed with port wine and is a popular addition to cheese boards and salads.

Other British Blues: A Growing Renaissance

In recent years, the UK has witnessed a resurgence in artisan cheesemaking, with new and innovative blue cheeses emerging across the country. These cheeses often utilize local milk and traditional techniques to create unique and flavorful products. Some notable examples include Shropshire Blue, a striking orange-hued cheese with a creamy texture and a tangy flavor, and Oxford Isis, a blue cheese washed in mead, resulting in a sweet and floral aroma.

Spain: A Hidden Gem of Blue Cheese Production

While not as widely known as French, Italian, or British blue cheeses, Spain boasts its own unique and flavorful varieties. Spanish blue cheeses often reflect the country’s diverse geography and culinary traditions.

Cabrales: A Rustic Mountain Treasure

Cabrales, produced in the Asturias region of northern Spain, is a strong and pungent blue cheese made from a blend of cow’s, sheep’s, and goat’s milk. Traditionally, the cheese is aged in natural caves in the Picos de Europa mountains, where the cool, humid environment promotes the growth of the Penicillium mold. Cabrales is known for its intense flavor and its crumbly texture. Its strong aroma and assertive taste make it a favorite among adventurous cheese lovers.

Picón Bejes-Tresviso: Another Asturian Delight

Also from Asturias, Picón Bejes-Tresviso is another blue cheese with Protected Designation of Origin. Like Cabrales, it’s typically made from cow’s milk, or a blend of cow’s, sheep’s, and goat’s milk, aged in limestone caves. It has a pungent, spicy flavor and a creamy, sometimes slightly granular, texture.

Beyond Europe: Blue Cheese Around the World

While Europe is the traditional heartland of blue cheese production, other countries around the world have also embraced this unique cheese. From the United States to Australia, cheesemakers are experimenting with different milk types, aging techniques, and Penicillium cultures to create their own distinct blue cheese varieties.

American Blue Cheese: A Modern Take

The United States has seen a surge in artisan cheesemaking in recent years, and American blue cheeses are gaining recognition for their quality and innovation. Many American cheesemakers are using locally sourced milk and experimenting with different aging techniques to create unique and flavorful blue cheeses. Some notable examples include Rogue River Blue, an Oregon-based blue cheese wrapped in grape leaves soaked in pear liqueur, and Bayley Hazen Blue, a Vermont-made blue cheese known for its creamy texture and its balanced flavor.

Oceanian Blues: Down Under Delights

Australia and New Zealand are also producing excellent blue cheeses, often using milk from grass-fed cows and sheep. These cheeses often exhibit a clean and grassy flavor, reflecting the region’s pastoral landscapes. Some popular examples include King Island Dairy Roaring Forties Blue from Australia and Kapiti Kikorangi from New Zealand.

Factors Influencing Blue Cheese Quality and Flavor

Numerous factors contribute to the overall quality and flavor of blue cheese. These include:

Type of Milk: Cow’s milk typically produces milder and creamier blue cheeses, while sheep’s and goat’s milk result in more pungent and complex flavors.
Penicillium Culture: The specific Penicillium culture used significantly impacts the cheese’s flavor profile.
Aging Process: The length and conditions of aging influence the cheese’s texture, flavor, and aroma.
Terroir: The environment in which the animals graze can also affect the milk’s composition and the cheese’s overall flavor.

So, Which Country Reigns Supreme?

Ultimately, the “best” country for blue cheese is a matter of personal taste. France boasts the most iconic and historically significant varieties, while Italy offers a diverse range of creamy and tangy blues. The United Kingdom is known for its bold and assertive flavors, while Spain offers rustic and pungent options. And the United States and other countries around the world are pushing the boundaries of blue cheese innovation.

The best way to determine your favorite blue cheese is to explore different varieties from various countries and discover the flavors that appeal most to your palate. Consider factors like the intensity of the flavor, the texture, and the type of milk used. Don’t be afraid to experiment with different pairings, such as fruit, nuts, wine, and crackers, to enhance your blue cheese experience.

What defines “best” when considering blue cheese?

Defining “best” in the context of blue cheese is subjective and multifaceted. It involves considering several factors, including the cheese’s flavor profile (ranging from mild and creamy to sharp and pungent), texture (crumbly, smooth, or spreadable), aroma, and overall balance. Personal preference plays a significant role, as some individuals may prefer a milder blue cheese suitable for salads, while others might crave a more intense variety to pair with wines or desserts.

Beyond individual taste, objective criteria also contribute to determining “best.” These include the quality of ingredients used (typically cow, sheep, or goat’s milk), the aging process (which influences the cheese’s flavor and texture), and the craftsmanship of the cheesemaker. Cheeses that consistently exhibit a well-developed flavor profile, a desirable texture, and are free from defects are generally considered superior.

What are some well-known blue cheeses from different countries?

France boasts several iconic blue cheeses, most notably Roquefort, a pungent, crumbly cheese made from sheep’s milk and aged in caves. Another popular French blue is Fourme d’Ambert, a milder and creamier cow’s milk cheese with subtle blue veining. These cheeses represent the spectrum of flavors that France offers.

Italy is also a significant player in the blue cheese world, producing cheeses like Gorgonzola, a cow’s milk cheese available in two main varieties: Dolce (sweet and creamy) and Piccante (sharp and intense). England is renowned for its Stilton, a rich and creamy cow’s milk blue cheese with a distinctive flavor, and the United States, while a relative newcomer, has developed innovative blue cheeses that compete with European standards.

How does the type of milk affect the flavor of blue cheese?

The type of milk used in blue cheese production significantly impacts the final flavor profile. Cow’s milk blue cheeses tend to be creamier and milder, often exhibiting buttery or nutty notes. They are generally more approachable for those new to blue cheese.

Sheep’s milk blue cheeses, like Roquefort, are typically sharper, tangier, and more pungent, owing to the higher fat content and distinct flavor compounds in sheep’s milk. Goat’s milk blue cheeses often possess a distinctive “goaty” flavor, sometimes described as earthy or tangy, and can vary widely in intensity depending on the specific goat breed and cheesemaking techniques.

What role does aging play in developing the flavor of blue cheese?

Aging is a crucial step in blue cheese production, directly impacting its flavor and texture. During aging, the mold (Penicillium) breaks down proteins and fats, releasing flavorful compounds that contribute to the cheese’s characteristic blue notes, ranging from mild and fruity to sharp and pungent.

The duration and environment of aging influence the specific flavors that develop. Longer aging periods generally result in more intense and complex flavors, while the humidity and temperature of the aging environment can affect the cheese’s texture, from crumbly to creamy. Some blue cheeses are aged in caves, where the unique microflora contribute to their distinct character.

What is the significance of Penicillium in blue cheese production?

Penicillium is the key ingredient that transforms ordinary cheese into blue cheese. Specific strains of Penicillium fungi, most commonly Penicillium roqueforti or Penicillium glaucum, are introduced during the cheesemaking process, either by adding spores directly to the milk or by injecting them into the formed cheese.

These fungi are responsible for the blue-green veins that characterize blue cheese. As the cheese ages, the Penicillium mold grows and metabolizes lactic acid, creating a higher pH environment, and breaks down proteins and fats. This enzymatic activity releases various compounds that contribute to the cheese’s characteristic flavor and aroma, including ketones, aldehydes, and free fatty acids.

What are some popular pairings for blue cheese?

Blue cheese, with its complex and often pungent flavor profile, pairs well with a variety of foods and beverages. Sweet accompaniments like honey, figs, and pears help to balance the cheese’s sharpness and bring out its sweeter notes. Conversely, savory pairings, such as walnuts, cured meats, and crusty bread, complement the cheese’s intensity.

Wine pairings depend on the specific type of blue cheese. Sweet wines like Sauternes or Port are excellent with rich and creamy blue cheeses like Stilton or Gorgonzola Dolce. Stronger, more assertive blue cheeses like Roquefort pair well with bold red wines such as Cabernet Sauvignon or Shiraz. Beer enthusiasts often enjoy pairing blue cheese with strong ales or stouts.

How can I best store blue cheese to maintain its quality?

Proper storage is essential for preserving the quality and flavor of blue cheese. Wrap the cheese tightly in wax paper or cheese paper, then place it in a resealable plastic bag or container. This helps to prevent the cheese from drying out and absorbing odors from other foods in the refrigerator.

Store blue cheese in the coldest part of your refrigerator, typically the crisper drawer or the bottom shelf. Consume the cheese within one to two weeks of purchase for optimal flavor and texture. Freezing blue cheese is not recommended, as it can significantly alter its texture and flavor. If mold appears beyond the typical veining, it is best to discard the cheese.